The Chicago Cubs' 2022 season was a rollercoaster, with some shining moments amidst a rebuilding phase. While the team didn't dominate, players like Willson Contreras and Ian Happ stood out, with the latter even bagging a Gold Glove. However, it was the performance of right-hander Scott Effross that truly caught attention.
Effross, a former 15th-round pick, emerged as a reliable arm in the Cubs' bullpen during the 2022 season. In 47 appearances, he showcased an impressive 2.66 ERA and 2.18 FIP, with an average of over 10 strikeouts per nine innings. His performance was a bright spot in an otherwise challenging season.
But here's where it gets controversial... Jed Hoyer, the Cubs' General Manager, made a bold move at the trade deadline, sending Effross to the New York Yankees in exchange for Hayden Wesneski. This move was met with frustration from many Cubs fans, as Effross was one of the team's best young relievers and still had years of team control at a low cost.
Effross finished the 2022 season strongly with the Yankees, posting a 2.13 ERA in 13 appearances. However, a 3.43 FIP hinted at potential issues. These concerns proved valid when, in October, Effross underwent Tommy John surgery, sidelining him for the entire 2023 season.
His struggles continued upon his return in 2024, with a back injury limiting his playing time. Despite impressive numbers at Triple-A, his performance dipped significantly, and in November, the Yankees decided to non-tender him.
And this is the part most people miss... Effross has now signed a minor-league deal with the Detroit Tigers, a clear indication of his diminished value since that breakout 2022 season. While he might get an invite to the big-league camp, he'll have to prove himself worthy of an MLB bullpen again.
Meanwhile, the Cubs' trade of Effross for Wesneski has had an interesting twist. Wesneski was later included in the Kyle Tucker trade, showcasing his value in Hoyer's roster-building strategy. Despite the initial backlash, cutting ties with Effross in 2022 now appears to be a strategic and timely decision.
So, was Jed Hoyer a genius for this trade? The answer might be more complex than a simple yes or no. What are your thoughts? Do you think Hoyer made the right call, or was it a risky move that didn't pay off? Let's discuss in the comments!
