When it comes to MMA legends, few debates ignite as much passion as the question of who deserves a spot on the sport's Mount Rushmore. But here's where it gets controversial: Justin Gaethje, the fighter widely hailed as the most thrilling athlete to ever step into the Octagon, has weighed in with his picks—and they’re bound to spark discussion. While Gaethje may not top the list in terms of championships or technical prowess, his choices for the MMA Mount Rushmore reveal a deep respect for the sport’s history and its trailblazers.
In a recent interview with Paramount+, Gaethje, who’s gearing up for his highly anticipated interim lightweight title fight against Paddy Pimblett at UFC 324 on January 24, shared his top four all-time greats. His selections included the undisputed GOAT Jon Jones, the versatile Georges St-Pierre, and the legendary Anderson Silva—a trio that often dominates these conversations. And this is the part most people miss: Gaethje’s fourth pick, Chuck Liddell, isn’t just a nod to the former light heavyweight champion’s in-ring achievements but also a tribute to his role in catapulting MMA into the mainstream. Liddell’s impact was so profound that even UFC President Dana White cites his knockout of Tito Ortiz as his favorite moment in UFC history.
But here’s the twist: Gaethje’s list conspicuously omits Khabib Nurmagomedov, the undefeated lightweight champion who choked him out in 2020. While Nurmagomedov’s perfect 29-0 record and dominance in the division make him a strong contender for many fans, Gaethje’s snub raises questions about whether a fighter’s personal legacy should influence these rankings. After all, Nurmagomedov’s protege, Islam Makhachev, is now challenging his mentor’s claim to the lightweight throne, adding another layer of complexity to the debate.
Gaethje’s choices aren’t just about skill or stats—they’re about the fighters who shaped the sport and inspired generations. Liddell, for instance, wasn’t just a champion; he was a cultural icon who helped MMA shed its underground reputation. But here’s the question that’ll keep fans talking: Should personal rivalries or career longevity factor into these selections? And does Nurmagomedov’s early retirement disqualify him from GOAT conversations?
As the MMA community continues to debate, one thing’s clear: Gaethje’s Mount Rushmore isn’t just a list—it’s a statement about the fighters who left an indelible mark on the sport. So, who’s on your Mount Rushmore? And do you agree with Gaethje’s bold choices? Let us know in the comments below—this is one debate that’s far from over.
